How rental cash flow is calculated
Cash flow is the money left from the rent after every cost of owning the property, the mortgage included. If it is positive, the tenant pays for the house and hands you the change. If it is negative, you feed the property from your paycheck every month. The calculator gets there in three steps:
Collected income = rent + other income − vacancyNOI = collected income − operating costsCash flow = NOI − mortgage principal and interest
Operating costs are property tax, insurance, HOA dues, utilities you pay, management, maintenance and a capex reserve. NOI (net operating income) leaves out the mortgage on purpose, so it describes the property no matter how it is financed. Income tax and depreciation are left out entirely; they depend on your own tax situation.
A worked example
Take the numbers the calculator opens with. A $250,000 house bought with 20% down needs a $200,000 loan. At 7% over 30 years, principal and interest come to $1,330.60 a month. The house rents for $2,100. Setting aside 5% for vacancy leaves $1,995 of collected rent.
Operating costs: $250 of property tax ($3,000 a year), $125 of insurance ($1,500 a year), $159.60 for an 8% manager, and $105 each for maintenance and capex at 5% of rent. That totals $744.60, so NOI is $1,250.40 a month, about $15,005 a year.
Cash flow = $1,250.40 − $1,330.60 = −$80.20 a month
The house loses about $962 a year. You would bring $57,500 to closing ($50,000 down plus $7,500 of closing costs), so the cash-on-cash return is −1.7%, while the cap rate is 6.0%.
Here is the trap: the same house passes a DSCR lender's test at 1.23, because the lender divides rent by principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA only. A lender will fund it. The repairs and the empty months are your problem, and they are exactly what pushes this one below zero.
Cash flow, cap rate and cash-on-cash
| Measure | How it is figured | What it tells you | In the example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash flow | NOI − mortgage P&I | Whether the property pays for itself every month | −$80 a month |
| Cap rate | Annual NOI ÷ price | The property's yield before any loan; compares deals and markets | 6.0% |
| Cash-on-cash | Annual cash flow ÷ cash invested | Your yearly return on the money you put in, with your loan | −1.7% |
The useful comparison is cap rate against your loan constant: a year of principal and interest divided by the loan, 7.98% here. When the cap rate is lower, each borrowed dollar costs more than it earns, so more debt means less cash flow. None of the three counts loan paydown or appreciation, which is why a property can be a decent long-term investment and still be a bad monthly cash flow deal.
The 1% and 50% rules
The 1% rule says monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price: $2,500 on a $250,000 house. The example rents for 0.84%, so it fails. The 50% rule says operating costs and vacancy will eat about half the rent over time, so cash flow is roughly half the rent minus principal and interest. Here that is $1,050 − $1,330.60, about −$281 a month.
Both are screens. They take ten seconds and ignore your actual tax bill, insurance quote, interest rate and the condition of the house. Use them to decide which listings deserve a full calculation, not which ones to buy.
They fail in predictable places. In expensive coastal metros, rents often run closer to 0.4% to 0.6% of the price, so almost nothing passes the 1% rule; buyers there are betting on appreciation and accepting thin or negative cash flow. In lower-priced Midwest markets the opposite happens: a $110,000 house renting for $1,200 clears 1% easily, but older housing, more turnover and costs that do not shrink with the price can push real expenses well past 50%. A roof, a furnace or an eviction costs about the same on a cheap house as on an expensive one.
Expenses new landlords forget
- Capex. Big items wear out on a schedule: an asphalt roof in roughly 20 to 30 years, a furnace or AC in 15 to 20, a water heater in 8 to 12. Saving 5% to 10% of rent each month turns a $12,000 surprise into a planned withdrawal.
- Vacancy. One empty month a year is 8.3% of the rent. Even a good tenant moves out eventually, and the gap between leases is rarely shorter than you hope.
- Turnover. Between tenants come cleaning, paint, small repairs, new locks, listing photos, and often a leasing fee of half to a full month's rent if a manager places the next tenant.
- Management. 8% to 10% of collected rent is typical, plus leasing and renewal fees. Price it in even if you self-manage: your time has a value, and life may hand the job to a manager later.
Smaller costs add up too. A landlord policy usually costs more than a homeowner policy on the same house, and lawn care, snow removal, pest control, bookkeeping and the occasional legal fee all come out of the same rent.
5 ways to improve cash flow
Starting from the example, which loses $80 a month:
- Pay less. At $235,000 the example breaks even. Price is the one number you lock in for as long as you own the house.
- Rent at market and add income. $2,250 of rent turns it into +$36 a month. Pet rent, parking or storage worth $75 a month adds about $58.
- Lower the rate. 6.25% instead of 7% gives +$19 a month. Putting more down helps less than it seems: 25% down reaches only +$3 a month and pushes cash-on-cash to roughly zero.
- Cut the fixed costs. Appeal an over-assessed tax bill and shop insurance every year: $2,700 of tax and $1,200 of insurance improve the result by $50 a month.
- Manage it yourself, with open eyes. Dropping the 8% fee gives +$79 a month, if you will answer the 10 PM call about the water heater. Do not get there by zeroing maintenance and capex: that makes the number look $210 better and changes nothing about the roof.